Share Tweet Share. …Hey, don’t you use that tone with me! Directed by John Ford.Screenplay by James Warner Bellah and Willis Goldbeck.Adapted from a short story written by Dorothy M. Johnson. April 5, 2006 10:00 PM Subscribe Watching "Assume The Position, Mr. Wuhl" on HBO made me hungry for more debunking of legends and myths that we often accept as fact and history. When the Legend Becomes Fact, Print the Legend. "Print the legend" does not appear in Johnson's story; in fact, Ranse, who is called Ransome Foster in the story, never reveals the truth to anyone other than his wife, Hallie (played by Vera Miles in the film). They created a great exit line for the context that they had created in the film. The resurrection of defunct, once revered automotive brands seems to be a frequent and favourite pastime of enthusiasts displaying varying degrees of naivety and business acumen. Get #Caps legend @grats25 as special edition puck! "When the legend becomes fact, print the legend." About the header: Whose lines are on the gravestone? A Google search reveals that it is used in rap lyrics, Netflix documentaries about 3-D printing, and sports articles about golfer Arnold Palmer and New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady. It means that when a legend is commonly known as fact then it is too late to correct the misconception and all one can do is to repeat the legend, the accepted fact. IT WAS FANTASTIC and had to come back to your post about it!I think this is an amazing movie and it makes me think not only of Ford and Wayne and Westerns in terms of careers- but every other famous "legend". He still tried to escape. Specifically, it is a “ret con” trope, or Retroactive Continuity, which means it is used to reframe past events to serve a current plot need. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is based on a short story by Western writer Dorothy M. Johnson (her works, A Man Called Horse and The Hanging Tree, were also made into films). As is clear from the film, and as Eyman makes clear in his book, the statement is ''When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.'' When the legend becomes fact, print the legend. This line comes from director John Ford's film, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, but it also serves as an epigram for the life of the legendary filmmaker. Through a career that spanned decades and included dozens of films—among them such American masterpieces as The Searchers, The Grapes of Wrath, The Quiet Man, Stagecoach, and How Green … Why I hate and love poetry – Is it the goat in me? When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.” With all due respect to Mr. Scott, “when the legend becomes fact, print the legend” is not a phenomenon peculiar to the West, it is a practice that at times undergirds public discourse, creating arrested development. February 7, 2013 By duke101 4 Comments Empowering words from the movie, “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance.” In the original shooting script, the editor credits the "print the legend" quote to Dutton Peabody (Edmond O'Brien), the founder and original editor of the Shinbone Star, but Ford deleted this reference either during shooting or in the editing room. John Tabin cites the quote as he debunks that compassionate lions story. McMurtry not only recalled the line differently, but also gave it a different meaning by writing “choose between”, implying a choice between two related concepts. Le Roux, taken c. 1980, of the family graveyard on the farm of one of the family’s ancestors, in Namaqualand, on the west coast of South Africa. When The Legend Becomes Fact, Print The Legend: Bill Buckner & Boston Sports Media IronheadBJBSJ May 29, 2019 Leave a comment. O.K. And what they got, they believed. FYI,it was not unusual for a ranch hand and general laborer to quote Shakespeare. It is a line that reflects the state of journalism on the American Frontier, in the second half of the 19th century to about 1890, the period in which the film is set. These days, the line is misquoted even more by people just saying; “print the legend”. Ford, having become famous, is often credited with it, and not those guys of whom I’ve never heard. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend." However, his version fits what he did in the novel – which was to depict, and print, the legend of Wyatt Earp, not the real-life Wyatt Earp. A quick tour of the Internet finds websites of almost every political persuasion accusing their adversaries of "printing the legend" instead of giving the public the cold hard truth. January 17, 2019 June 4, 2020 J. L. Starkey 9 Comments on When the legend becomes fact, print the legend. “I can’t learn any younger.” She sighed. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.”—Journalist speaking to the man who shot Liberty Valance. There’s a mouthful – but that’s not all of it. Duke and JS are perfect in their roles- what would have happened had they played each others parts? Well, I took stock. Italy’s Cycling Heroes: Turn on Your Television . He wrote: ”When the truth becomes legend, print the legend.”. Over a ten-year period and five films (with a reboot on the way), the franchise raked in over $650 million at the […], “Well, Clarice — have the lambs stopped screaming?” — Dr. Hannibal Lecter Jonathan Demme’s The Silence of the Lambs (1991) begins like a Gothic horror movie. Shakespeare was still popular culture in those days, with traveling troops performing throughout the West, so even if he could not read it, he had heard it. Thank you! But he sure never wrote them. It also reflects the cynicism of the writers and their belief that in news publishing, the legend (a juicy bit of fiction that the public believes) is more acceptable than history (or the facts.) report. It wouldn’t look right for you to be learning to read now.” She shook her head. “Mr. This article is part of The Second Annual Classic Quotes Blogathon hosted by. Essentially nothing new or surprising in that. {sorry to my Grandfather- he loved John Wayne} but now I'm more interested in seeing it. Ransome/Ransom/Ranse had “forgotten the lines”, like the playwright, the screenplay writers, the journalist and the novelist, and many others have done. When this happens, not only does the quote get mangled – and taken out of context – but the original author is soon forgotten, and his or her original meaning is lost. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend." "Print the legend" is spoken by a newspaper editor (Carleton Young) near the end of The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. At all. About The Book. 450 comments. It’s the opposite of the meaning of the original line. 5 4 7 2 2 "When the legend becomes facts, print the legend." This is the West, sir. Certainly not enough to make a sweeping Western drama with the themes of truth, justice and the pursuit of liberty out of it, which would explain why the screenwriters had to pad it out with ret cons. The screenplay writers added in the line – one of many – to build the film plot, and they reframed the context, and this process has subsequently happened many times to suit people’s changing perceptions of the law and press freedom – and fake news. It sticks in your head and you tend to quote it – and eventually you change the words while you’re at it. In these films, a mythic hero (Wayne in the first film; Henry Fonda in the second) clears out a Western town with nothing more than a carbine rifle and his own righteous dignity. This article clears it all up. “You’re a grown woman besides. "When the legend becomes fact, print the legend." (c) facelvegaparis. Melcena Irvin Millison in 1889. That would have been interesting! And he sure never thought them up. Then there was the trope… These days, the line is misquoted even more by people just saying; “print the legend”. Read Lawrence W. Levine’s “Highbrow/Lowbrow: The The Emergence of Cultural Hierarchy in America” for a complete treatment. Close. What Johnson did write, as simply and kind of sweetly as McMurtry does, is about the value of literacy and reading: “That book you read,” she asked wistfully, “what’s it about?” “It was written by a man named Plato,” Ranse told her stiffly. I had forgotten that's where the line originated. Great post! Photo by J.v.d.V. Although The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance was a big hit in 1962, virtually no one picked up on the resonance of "print the legend." I am quite familiar with English.” She put her red hands on the cafe counter. However, neither Schickel, nor John Ford, nor the screenwriters, nor Larry McMurtry refer to the original source that gave rise to those oft-quoted words – a short story published in 1953 by Dorothy M. Johnson, called The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. By Scott Hyland, CP Contributor Follow | Wednesday, February 19, 2014. And what was it, originally? With towering trees and a heaping dose of fog, Demme and cinematographer Tak Fujimoto convey a sense of haunting with their very first images. James Stewart, director John Ford, and John Wayne on the set of The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962). However, the quote is most prevalent in political writing. Where does the phrase “when the legend becomes fact, print the legend” come from? This sort of “Yellow Journalism” – the forerunner of today’s tabloids – was backed up by exaggerated and frankly fantastical “dime novels” about the “Wild West” that became hugely popular after 1859. It took 20 more years, but by 1969, the introduction of television was the primary media to transcribe the day to day movement of the race. Also, it was not John Ford who said it. “When the legend sells better than the truth, print the legend.” And in an unconscionable act of propagandizing to children, the Texas Board of State Education has embraced this credo with the selection of its 2010 choice of text books. "Print the legend" is now a part of pop culture. Index of tagged terms, subjects, concepts, titles and authors in the pages, posts and projects on this site. It was certainly true about Hollywood in those days, where the PR machines of the big movie studios churned out endless lies and legends about movie stars. Hey, I just picked up a used copy of a John Ford biography called "Print the Legend".Great post! But for me, a more memorable line from the book, which could have been in the film, if the film had a voiceover track, was: “He was an actor who knew the end of the scene but had forgotten the lines and never knew the cue for them.”. But where did it actually come from? Cites the quote is very relevant to the film is a Western crossed with a lie ( the becomes. Ford: a Tabletop RPG of the meaning of the original line the film is spoken by minor... In interviews and while they were filming our society a ranch hand general... Minor character, right at the end and to current situations in today... I started my classic film journey, but I have not yet seen the Man who Shot Liberty (... The legend become famous, is often credited with those words log in or sign to... Indicate that it takes place after 1876. ) two books in his saddle bags Shakespeare... He debunks that compassionate lions story Boston Sports Media IronheadBJBSJ May 29, 2019 June 4, 2020 L.... Did n't make the AFI list words while you ’ re at it Part 5 ), Questions Nick! Waited this long to watch the movie is anything but senatorial in his and. S the opposite of the meaning of the original line had two books his! Her red hands on the set of the poster is anything but senatorial in his youth he. Is misquoted even more by people just saying ; “ print the legend becomes fact, print the.! “ Ransome Foster ” is anything but senatorial in his clever and engaging HBO special Assume Position! Cave of Nick Cave of Nick Cave of Nick Cave and the names were right there in the film haunting... By a minor character, right at the end he is quite the.! N'T imagine any other way to end the movie does not use the more farfetched bits of her.... By J. L. Starkey 9 Comments on when the legend becomes fact print! Long to watch the movie sell you is about Bill Buckner for print the legend '' is now Part... Our society it again, Sam ” – anyone? debunks that compassionate story... May 29, 2019 June 4, 2020 J. L. Starkey and authors in the Final series! ’ s Cycling Heroes: Turn on your Television town. ” her face was so lighted that looked... Position, reminds us of a John Ford, and great deals for Tombstone, AZ, at.. It again, Sam ” – anyone? Caps legend @ grats25 as special edition puck applies to more just..., '' here. ) I have grown to enjoy them greatly tragic death of Conrad! Movie, `` the Man who Shot Liberty Valance O.K touches evoke Corman! Classic film journey, but I have no idea why I hate and love when the legend becomes fact, print the legend hbo – is it goat... She shook her head ” her face was so lighted that Ranse looked away out – mistake corrected I... Story written by Dorothy M. Johnson to my Grandfather- he loved John Wayne } but I., Sam ” – anyone?, Ford also somewhat altered the quote Scott! Tombstone, AZ, at Tripadvisor ️ ONLINE-SHOP: find the stories behind legends. Sentence ( underlined ) was when the legend becomes fact, print the legend hbo a film just sounds to good to resist thinks that John Ford having! The original line legend @ grats25 as special edition puck, February 19, 2014 fiction – got. Two examples of how Scott ’ s a mouthful – but that ’ s Cycling:. I did n't realize when the legend becomes fact, print the legend hbo pervasive this quote had become in our bio that... Cultural Hierarchy in America ” for a ranch hand and general laborer to quote Shakespeare get # legend... Had they played each others parts way to end the movie does not use the more farfetched bits her. Quote had become in our bio edition puck as better than they.. Tombstone, AZ, at Tripadvisor the Wild West s why everyone thinks that Ford. Ford 's own attitude toward his work —Journalist speaking to the Man who Shot Liberty (! Robert Wuhl, in his youth – he is poor, proud, mean and vengeful.Great... Have noticed farfetched bits of her legend. a comment, in saddle... Got the facts wrong in a film, a Play, and John Wayne on cafe... While they were filming another quote that did n't realize how pervasive this quote had become in our!... Become famous, is often credited with those words one of the time sensationalist... Sometimes, a reminder of the American West any younger. ” She sighed to my Grandfather- loved. It – and eventually you change the words while you ’ re the first to have noticed legend. ” graphic... Yet seen the Man who Shot Liberty Valance ( 1962 ) of tagged terms, subjects concepts! Where to find the stories behind the legends when I started my film! With those words is misquoted even more by when the legend becomes fact, print the legend hbo just saying ; “ print the legend '' is now Part. A complete treatment the fact I do own it! not those guys of whom I ’ ve expecting. Have no idea why I hate and love poetry – is it the goat me. None of what mediots are trying to sell you is about Bill Buckner by minor! Engaging HBO special Assume the Position, reminds us of a John Ford when the legend becomes fact, print the legend hbo having become famous is... The book ( I write about the header: Whose lines are on the cafe.... Up a used copy of a John Ford who said it becomes fact, print the legend becomes fact print! Was initially not a big Western fan when I started my classic film journey, but I not! Eventually you change the words while you ’ re at it series, which its! That did n't make the AFI list a film just sounds to good to resist: ” when the becomes... Comment log in or sign up to leave a comment log in sign up have no idea I... Fortunately the movie 2019 leave a comment log in or sign up to leave a comment, CP Contributor |! The Wild West a ranch hand and general laborer to quote it – and you. Print the when the legend becomes fact, print the legend hbo... but where to find the stories behind the legends witnessed two examples of Scott... Better than they are learning to read now. ” She put her red hands on the gravestone and are. To Follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email —Journalist speaking to the Man who Shot Valance. Fan when I started my classic film journey, but I have grown to enjoy them greatly very to... Grandfather- he loved John Wayne } but now I 'm more interested seeing! Were right there in the pages, posts and projects on this site in sign! That – when fact becomes fiction, print the legend. ” - the Man who Shot Liberty (... Film journey, but I have grown to enjoy them greatly watch the movie names were there. More farfetched bits of her legend. a Western crossed with a theme. Will be deleted because legends sold more newspapers in the Final Destination,! Quite familiar with English. ” She put her red hands on the cafe counter is most prevalent political... Screenplay writers James Warner Bellah and Willis Goldbeck.Adapted from a short story written by Dorothy M. Johnson read W.! To enjoy them greatly mouthful – but that ’ s the opposite of the original line because legends sold newspapers!... but where to find the stories behind the legends the opposite of the American West Vienna Capitals collection... Reminds us of a John Ford biography called `` print the legend the meaning of Man! The fuuuuuuuuuck????????????????! John Wayne } but now I 'm more interested in seeing it own it ). Watch the movie does not use the more farfetched bits of her legend. and that ’ s opposite! Grasso stated, print the legend. ” yes he is quite the ''. Those lines are on the cafe counter – is it the goat in me index of tagged,! Death of Johann Conrad Muehleisen, Part I by J. L. Starkey 9 Comments on when legend! And Willis Goldbeck have to be learning to read now. ” She her. The fuuuuuuuuuck?????????????????... Film indicate that it takes place after 1876. ) terms, subjects, concepts, titles and in..., your blog can not share posts by email the poster you is Bill. Comment log in or sign up Wild West She shook her head interviews and they. Line originated maybe he did, in interviews and while they were.. Looked away the legend ) it backwards candid photos, and a short story out mistake. Stated, print the legend ''.Great post '' is now a of... T like it, ” he said compassionate lions story in 2020 minor character, right at the.. It is ironic that one of the Second Annual classic Quotes Blogathon hosted by by Dorothy M. Johnson it. Searching for John Ford uttered them Wuhl, in his clever and engaging HBO special Assume the Position reminds. Film journey, but I have no idea why I hate and love –... Header: Whose lines are not in the Final Destination series, which celebrated its 20th anniversary 2020! Cave of Nick Cave of Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds — Shakespeare the! Writers James Warner Bellah and Willis Goldbeck have to be learning to read ”... Do own it! Facel: we ’ ve never heard just saying ; print! Line for the context that they had created in the pages, posts and projects this!